Every Suggestion Is Also a Verdict

Sep 22, 2026

Connect

I made a suggestion to a friend going through her divorce. Just a side comment, barely a thought.

"I don't want to do that," she said. Fast. Flat.

Her walls went up before I'd even finished the sentence.

Got it, I thought. I overstepped.

It felt like help when I said it. It landed as criticism when she heard it. Same sentence, two completely different things, depending on which side of it you're standing on.

Here's what I didn't want to admit: a suggestion is never just information. It also says something else, whether I mean it to or not. It says, you're not quite doing this right. Even when I don't believe that. Even when I love the person. The suggestion carries the message anyway.

This wasn't the first time I've done this. It won't be the last, if I'm honest. And every time it happens, something small gets spent. A little less of the safety that made her tell me anything in the first place.

If you're in the middle of something hard and someone hands you an improvement, you don't just hear the improvement. You hear that you're currently getting it wrong. That's true even when the suggestion is small. Especially when it's small, because a throwaway comment means it seemed obvious to them, which means my situation looked simple from the outside. It isn't.

I wasn't trying to criticize her. But I wasn't asked, either. And an unasked-for suggestion doesn't get to choose how it's received.

Next time a suggestion is sitting on the tip of your tongue, try this instead: ask "do you want my thoughts, or do you just need me to listen?" Let them answer before you say the rest.

The ACE Assessment can show you where you default to offering solutions instead of asking what's actually wanted, even with people you love. 138 questions, 20 minutes, then a full hour with me to walk through what it shows.

Take the ACE Assessment → https://ace.bethoughtly.com/

In your corner,

Allison

Responses

Join the conversation

t("newsletters.loading")

The Leader Who Kept Being Right and Kept Losing

He spent six hours writing an SOP nobody was going to read. He just didn't know that yet. Something had gone wrong on his team, so he did what he always does. Sat down, thought it through, wrote it up clean, formatted it, printed it, posted it. Then he told the team about it. They didn't follow it. So he found backup. Articles, videos, proof his SOP was right. He sent it around. Surely once the...

The Sound of Skidding Tires

A client of mine runs a team that's stretched thin. Open positions everywhere, nobody to fill them, the people he does have running on fumes. Last session, he told me he'd figured it out. He'd built a real plan. Smart, well thought out, the kind of thing that actually could work. His next move: walk in and tell his team the plan. I heard the tires skid before he even finished the sentence. "Who...

She Went From 80-Hour Weeks to 50, Without Losing a Dollar

A friend of mine took over a business four years ago. Over the first few years, she learned something that stopped me when she said it. "I've learned I'm not that important." I pushed back. She runs the place. The buck stops with her. That's exactly the belief she had to unlearn. As the leader, she assumed every decision was hers to own, which meant every decision had to be defensible. Made the...

Every Suggestion Is Also a Verdict

Responses

Welcome to Thoughtly

Breathing life into your leadership

DOWNLOAD THE FREE GUIDE